756: The Number Of The Best
Baseball season is about one-third gone in 2007. Barry Bonds
is about 10 homers away from setting the all-time home run record
. It's controversial—baseball is pretending Bonds isn't really nearing a milestone, and it's all because of the book "Game of Shadows."
Sorry, but I'm celebrating Bonds' 756.
This a tough issue for me because I'm still not convinced that performance-enhancing substances
improve the stats of hitters who are already productive. I was watching the Cubs and Braves one weekend, and I noticed how one Braves outfielder has changed over the years. He's still as tall as he was when he started and as joyful in his expressions. But he looks a little older and a little thicker with age. I remember an Orioles' outfielder in the '90s was known for his meticulous workouts and he was in perfect shape. But he wasn't a big star—he was just in killer shape.
When Babe Ruth moved into Yankee Stadium
in 1923—"The House That Ruth Built"—he continued his home run legend. The right field fence was 295 feet away; The Babe, however, had begun hitting homers by the dozen before Yankee Stadium. Hammerin' Hank Aaron
himself enjoyed an Atlanta ballpark known as "the launching pad" for its homer-friendly dimensions. In 2000, Bonds moved into PacBell Park (now SBC) after years in other, less friendly ballparks, but his numbers show he was a game-changer even in the cavernous parks.
Willie Mays
, on the other hand, hit 660 career homers in a career that was spent in Candlestick Park
in San Francisco: windy, cold, deep and stingy. Put his right-handed bat in Fenway Park
and what do you have? We can only guess.
I watched Bonds play since he came to S.F. in 1993. Every game, seems like, he drives in the clutch run, scares the other pitcher and manager to death, makes the good play in left. After the controversial years began, that did not change. I notice his stats are pretty consistent
except for a couple of incredible home run years. He's the best hitter ever, from this fan's standpoint—he comes up and everything changes. Everything.
So I myself can only accept the moral dimension with substance abuse—drugs are addictive and bad for you. But I am not yet convinced that they enhance hitting. Before or after the controversy, Bonds has always been pretty good at that. Like, "best ever!" good.




Comments
I'll remind you the next time you want to celebrate the homerun achievements of one of these four
Ken Griffey Jr 563
Reg Jackson 563
Mike Schmidt 548
Mick Mantle 536
These four are not in the top 10 BUT we have 4 in the top 10 who are "highly" suspected of taking enhancement drug. When did flat-out wrong become w-e-ll, let's make believe we don't know or just ignore it or find a lawyer who will fight for it in court.
Posted by: black & white | June 10, 2007 11:13 AM
All I'm sayin', b&w, is I'm just not convinced that performance is enhanced. Shorter fences, bigger guys... It seems to me it comes down to who can hit.
That's all I'm sayin'...
Posted by: Charles Riggs | June 11, 2007 02:06 PM
Let Barry have his record, but do not let him into the Hall of Fame in his lifetime. Any player who casts a shadow upon the game - ie Pete Rose, Black Sox - can have their records stand, but can only be elected into the HOF posthumously.
Posted by: greg | June 12, 2007 09:58 AM
Thanks, Greg. My opinion is that Bonds is the King, but your opinion is just as valid. There's a moral dimension to the controversy that I accept.
But I still say, I'm not convinced that performance is enhanced -- especially with somebody who's already AMAZING.
Posted by: Charles Riggs | June 12, 2007 10:30 AM
I really enjoyed your article. I was looking for art sculptures but came across your writing. It is refreshing what you wrote. You put into words what no one else is saying. I don't follow baseball although I am a Tiger's fan. I feel saddened by the absolute stance that some fans position themselves into. I try to always remember that we will be judged the way we judge others.
Posted by: Alex | August 4, 2007 11:44 AM
Thanks, Alex.
Barry is amazing. If he did what everybody is mad at him about, my position is --
a) it does't matter
b) I ain't convinced it's an issue anyway.
All roads thus lead to one conclusion: He's the champ and deserves our awe.
Plus, the 755th last night was a pitch Barry muscled to the opposite field. I've seen that happen so often the last 15 years. That's the basis of my opinion. He's better than any controversy.
Posted by: Charles Riggs | August 5, 2007 01:27 PM
So true.
Posted by: Abe | August 6, 2007 12:40 PM